Should I Rent Out Or Sell My House?

A lot of homeowners that are thinking about moving have an option with their home: rent it out or sell it? What to do hinges on various factors, including one’s financial situation and local market conditions. Let’s explore the key aspects to consider, including the financial implications of both options.

Deciding Between Selling and Renting Out Your Home:
A home is often the largest financial asset for many people, making the decision of what to do with it a significant one. Selling your home offers a substantial cash windfall, while renting it provides a steady monthly income. Renting also allows you to continue building equity if property values rise. Consider your personal circumstances to determine the best choice.

When Selling is the Best Option:

Need Cash for Next Home Purchase: If buying a new home depends on the cash from selling your current one, selling is your best option. This approach allows you to apply the proceeds towards a new down payment.
Not Interested in Landlord Responsibilities: Managing a rental property requires time and effort. If you’re not prepared for the responsibilities of being a landlord, such as maintenance and tenant management, selling might be preferable.
Potential for Significant Profit: With property values increasing nationwide, selling your home could result in substantial profit. Analyze your local real estate market to gauge potential gains.
Eligibility for Capital Gains Tax Exemptions: If your home was your primary residence for at least two of the past five years, you may qualify for significant capital gains tax exemptions, making selling financially advantageous.
When Renting Out is a Better Choice:

Temporary Relocation: If you’re moving temporarily and plan to return, renting out your home can be more cost-effective than selling and later buying another property.
Desire for Rental Income: Extra income from renting can be appealing, but remember, if you’re buying another home, lenders will consider your rental income when assessing your mortgage eligibility.
High Rental Demand: If your home is in a sought-after location, renting can be a smart move. Evaluate the rental market in your area to ensure finding tenants is feasible.
Expectation of Property Value Increase: If you anticipate an increase in your home’s value in the near future, renting now and selling later could maximize your profits.
Cost Considerations in Renting vs. Selling:

Costs of Renting Out: These include mortgage payments, maintenance, finding tenants, potential vacancies, property management fees, HOA fees, and landlord insurance.
Costs of Selling: Preparing your home for sale, real estate commissions, closing fees, home staging, and paying off your mortgage are some of the expenses involved in selling.
Economic Downturn Considerations:
With potential recessions, assess your job stability and financial resilience. If you’re unsure about managing two mortgages or dealing with reduced rental income, selling might be the safer option.

Bottom Line:
Choosing between renting and selling your home requires a thorough evaluation of your financial status, lifestyle, and the local housing market. Weigh the costs of both options, consider your future plans, and your willingness to take on landlord responsibilities before making a decision. Of course schedule a free consult on our website and we can let you know how your specific situation looks when we crunch the numbers.